Here’s one of the most talked about story this week - the refusal of the Shady Oak pub in Fernilee

With more than 100 comments it seems everyone has something to say on The Shady Oak pub in Fernilee losing out on planning permission.

High Peak Borough Council rejected the plans to convert the former pub into a four-bedroomed home.

The application proposed to change the use of the ground floor from public house to residential accommodation to create a 4-bedroom detached property. All changes would have been internal.

However this was rejected by the planning officers and when we shared the news on Facebook page it quickly became the most commented story of the week.

Here’s the most talked about story this week - the refusal of a planning application for the the Shady Oak in Fernilee Photo google mapsplaceholder image
Here’s the most talked about story this week - the refusal of a planning application for the the Shady Oak in Fernilee Photo google maps

Ciara Curran said: “Bit like the Taxal Lodge, refused planning, now it’s rotting away, High Peak planners hate change.

“And they hate allowing private folk to do what they like with their properties but they are okay with building hundreds of houses on green belt.”

Percy Mycock asked when was the last time anyone on here called for a pint.

He said: “People aren't going out the same. I'm all for looking after some pubs but the remaining few that go to pubs can't keep them all open so it might as well be saved as a building.”

Carol Whitehead was also in favour of the change.

She said “It should be allowed to change to a house, at least then won't become derelict.”

Sally Mellers commented that not enough time was given to see if anyone else wanted to run it as a pub.

She said: “There was no proof submitted that it was unprofitable.

“The doors had only been closed a couple of months or so when it was sold on.

“Unfortunately the last managers were in for approx nine months and pretty much ran it into the ground, to the point where loyal locals like me no longer went in.

“They had no previous pub experience, but there were other issues too.

“The planning process was not followed by the new owner to even give this place a chance of staying a pub.

“I know times are difficult and there would be no guarantees, but at least a fighting chance should have been given, or maybe some compromise with a house conversion and a small bar, which some of the locals might well have supported, both financially and with their time.

“However the pub was ripped apart before anything like this could be even considered or looked into.

“Yes, if all other options fail, then allow the conversion. But there are planning rules that we all have to follow.”

Gaz Goodier did not see a future for the pub.

He said: “The Shady Oak has had several landlords and the place just isn't a viable business so it will never make it.

“It would make a lovely home for a family.”

Diane Cooper suggested changing to a smaller pub and at least one holiday let would surely be much better.

And Lee Maneke added: “The moment you turn a dive into a goldmine the brewery steals every penny of it with increased rents and barrelage costs.

“Taking on a pub is the worst franchise in the world and yet folk still queue up to do it.”

News you can trust since 1852
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice