Calls for HPBC to reverse Carelink closure - an 'essential' service for elderly and vulnerable people
The closure of Carelink services has been discussed by High Peak Borough Councillors at a Full Council meeting.
On Wednesday July, 2 High Peak Borough Councillors discussed the loss of the service at Full Council, however press and public were excluded from the discussion as the matters were relating to the financial affairs of those staff affected including the Council as the holder of that information.
Councillors had previously scrutinised a recommendation to close the service at a meeting of the Community Select Committee on 20 May, before the executive made its final decision on 11 June.
Carelink is an alarm system which enables elderly, vulnerable and disabled people to live independently by allowing them to call a contact centre and seek help from a trained member of staff 24 hours a day from anywhere in their home or garden.


However, the news that the service will be lost by September 30 has sent ripples across the High Peak with people worrying about their safety and the safety of their loved ones.
Resident Sally Riding said: “I am dismayed at your decision to close the care link service and my disgust at the way the decision was taken.
“I realise that the devious and underhand way in which you made the decision to close the care link service means l have very little hope of receiving an open and transparent answer to any of my questions but as l know there are hundreds of other people in our community also searching for the same answers, l will persevere.”
Sally’s mum is a 92-year-old widow with very advanced age related macular degeneration who lives alone and is only able to do so because of the peace of mind and security that the Carelink service offers to the whole family.


Sally said: “My mum has been using Carelink since my dad passed slightly over five years ago, and during that time she has used the service three times.
“The most recent time was in April of this year when she fell and was unable to get up.
“She did not realise that she cut her leg in the fall until the Carelink staff arrived.
“The cut required hospital treatment and the wound is still being dressed and monitored by the district nurse team almost three months later.”
She said not only was her mum very scared at the time of the accident but also what the potential implications would have been if her mum had not been able to contact Carelink at the time of her fall.
High Peak Borough Councillor Kath Sizeland opposes the decision to cut these services and at the meeting called on the executive to reverse the decision.
She also urged the council to explore all options so that this ‘essential service can continue to provide the excellent work it is renowned for’.
Councillor Sizeland said: “Despite passionate and well reasoned arguments from Conservative and Independent Councillors, and backed by the NHS and many Carelink Service users.
“We are deeply disappointed that the decision to close the Carelink Service could not be overturned.
“We made a case that Carelink is far more than just a response service.
“It provides a vital lifeline to some of our most vulnerable residents in our community, helping them live safely and independently while preventing unnecessary pressure on the NHS and Emergency Services.
“We also called for more scrutiny, greater transparency, and a full assessment of the impact of this closure on residents and partner organisations. Sadly these concerns were dismissed.
“Thank you to everyone who supported the campaign, spoke up, and stood with us.
“Your voices matter, even if it wasn’t the result we wanted.”
She said she will continue to stand up for the residents and hold the Council to account for the consequences of this decision.
Derbyshire County Councillor for Buxton Melandra Smith said: “Carelink has provided a vital 24-hour emergency alarm service for elderly, disabled and vulnerable High Peak residents, enabling many people to remain independent in their own homes while providing reassurance to families and carers.
“The loss of such a service is therefore a matter of considerable public interest.
“High Peak Borough Council states that Carelink is a discretionary service and says it has struggled for several years to recruit and retain sufficient staff to operate the service safely.
"Are residents to understand that the published reason for closure is therefore staffing-related rather than financial?
“The residents who depend upon Carelink deserve complete transparency regarding this decision.
“Many are among the most vulnerable members of our community, and their families will understandably be concerned about the future.”
High Peak Borough’s Executive Councillor for Housing, Fiona Sloman, was present at the Full Council meeting to explain that the ‘decision was not taken lightly nor was it a decision based on the need to make financial savings’. It was, she says, taken purely on issues of safeguarding.
Councillor Sloman said: “The service, which is a discretionary one, involves helping vulnerable people and so safeguarding has to be the number one priority for the council.
“This means meeting our legal obligations to provide a safe and robust service and delivering on our contractual requirements.
“This has become a critical issue for us and despite concerted efforts to improve the situation it is, sadly, worsening and therefore action needs to be taken.
Councillor Sloman said those contractual requirements revolve around the council’s continuing inability to maintain ‘adequate staffing levels’.
“We have eight staff, but we need 20 to run a safe service,” she said.
“Recruitment is very challenging despite repeated attempts to recruit and retain new staff.
“Similar services in the private sector are chasing the same small pool of potential workers and there has been the loss of a potential workforce we could once recruit from following the UK’s withdrawal from the EU.”
She says despite the council offering higher hourly rates than similar providers, they struggled to find staff for various reasons including the challenges of getting around the large High Peak area, the often-unsocial hours, and the need for our eight staff to do extra hours to meet customer demands which is not sustainable and potentially a dangerous situation if it leads to tired staff.
In a release sent out after the meeting Councillor Sloman said: “As we have said publicly and in letters to all our customers and their carers, we don’t want anyone to worry about the decision we have made.
“We are in the process of speaking to all our customers personally over the coming weeks to provide information about other providers of telecare services available to them that they can
access and help them arrange alternative support if they need it.
“We are equally grateful to our Carelink staff who continue to provide quality, dedicated services in difficult circumstances.”
A Careline Working Group was set up with cross party membership, to work alongside an internal Carelink Project Board, to manage with care and empathy the withdrawal of the service at the end of September.
This group of seven nominated councillors will continue to meet each fortnight.