LETTER: Use rail instead of Peak pipeline to move C02
Your article on the proposed Peak Cluster was most informative, not least in alerting me to what the scheme proposers have OMITTED to do.
In their assessment of methods of moving the CO2 they have completely omitted the possibility of moving it by railfreight. The only surface transport they appear to have considered is using road tankers, and in an effort to "frighten the horses" they suggest this would need 400 truck movements a day.


In breaking this figure down, that is 200 loaded HGVs and 200 empty returns. In turn this needs to be split between the 4 plants involved, i.e., 50 each way at each plant daily. 50 HGV loads are well within the capability of railfreight, which typically carries 60-75 HGV loads on a single train. All 4 plants are currently rail connected, 3 of them having dozens of freight train movements daily.
To summarise, moving the CO2 by rail would require ONE train daily (6 day week) each way to each plant. This pales into insignificance compared to existing rail movements and would be far less intrusive than a pipeline, with its cost, disruption and ongoing presence in the form of above ground infrastructure. An additional benefit of rail is the ability to send the product anywhere in the country, where other similar schemes are being built, rather than being restricted to a single delivery point.
What do you think? Share your thoughts on this – or any other subject – via [email protected]