The Select side were 1-0 up at half-time thanks to a fine finish from Paul Sullivan and after the goal they looked in solid control.
However, the second 45 minutes was a totally different story with the Rag completely overpowering their opponents.
Goals from Pete Richardson, who scored a brace, Luke Dowin and Damian High completely changed the perspective of the game.
The Select side briefly got themselves back into the contest through Sullivan again, but the strike proved to be no more than a consolation.
Buxton beef up with new quartet - and more could be on the way
Longnor Races will be back in 2022, organisers confirm
Ambition and love for the club key to Diego De Girolamo signing new Buxton deal
Former Buxton boss Steve Cunningham hits out at social media rumours and reveals the real reason why he quit
Rebuild will take time says New Mills joint manager Dave Birch after defeat double
After the game the trophy was presented by Scotty’s parents Steve and Jayne.