Transport Secretary urges Derbyshire council to fix potholes after highlighting Chesterfield neighbourhood’s problems

Derbyshire County Council’s highways chief believes residents will start to notice a ‘real difference’ in the quality of roads in the next year after the council suffered criticism for on-going pothole problems in a Chesterfield neighbourhood and for its poor showing under a new rating system.

The Labour Government’s Transport Secretary urged the Reform UK-led council to repair its roads after a Department for Transport report gave the council a low ‘Red’ rating for tackling potholes.

This comes as the East Midlands Labour Party Group and Chesterfield’s Labour MP highlighted continuing problems on and around Holland Road, at Whittington, in Chesterfield.

Cllr Charlotte Hill, Cabinet Member for Potholes, Highways and Transport, said: “We’ve made great progress on highways maintenance since May.

Pothole Problems Around Holland Road, At Whittingtonplaceholder image
Pothole Problems Around Holland Road, At Whittington

“Over the summer months we cleared the massive backlog of potholes and have resurfaced many roads and pavements. We know there is more to do, and appreciate residents communicating issues directly with the council.

“I believe that residents will start to notice a real difference in the quality of our roads in the next year as the measures we are introducing start to take shape.

“But the data in this report, looks from 2020, until June 2025, using historic data, and a few weeks into my role as Highways Cabinet Member.”

The Reform UK-led council was given the lowest ‘Red’ rating with 12 other councils in the Labour Government’s Department for Transport’s new traffic light ratings aimed at measuring how well councils are tackling potholes with ‘Amber’ indicating room for improvement and ‘Green’ indicating best practice.

Pictured, Left To Right, Are Labour Chesterfield Mp Toby Perkins, Labour Chesterfield Borough Cllr Alan Ogle, And Labour Transport Minister Lillian Greenwood, In Whittington, Chesterfieldplaceholder image
Pictured, Left To Right, Are Labour Chesterfield Mp Toby Perkins, Labour Chesterfield Borough Cllr Alan Ogle, And Labour Transport Minister Lillian Greenwood, In Whittington, Chesterfield

Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander, who spoke out on National Pothole Day, said: “Yet again Reform has shown their promises to voters in Derbyshire are just words. To only carry out sticking plaster fixes when they are receiving record funding from this Government is shameful.

“And we know Whittington is just one example of this failure. Labour MPs and councillors across the county hear time and time again from residents about the pothole plague on their roads and the damage it causes to their vehicles.

“Drivers are the ones paying the price for Reform’s lack of action. If they want to be in power, they need to step up.”

Labour Government Transport Minister Lilian Greenwood and Chesterfield Labour MP Toby Perkins visited Whittington, in April, last year, to highlight the extent of pothole problems in this neighbourhood after criticism from the RAC and when the former Conservative administration still ran the county council just before Reform’s election success in May.

Derbyshire County Cllr Charlotte Hillplaceholder image
Derbyshire County Cllr Charlotte Hill

The East Midlands Labour Group claims that after revisiting the same streets in Whittington in January, Labour found the concrete is still puckered with potholes and only minor patchwork fillings had taken place despite arguing that the authority has received a Government funding boost to fix roads.

Mr Perkins said: “Last year, both Labour and Reform called out the Conservative-led Derbyshire County Council for their shameful record on our roads and it is shocking that, despite now being in charge and receiving record funding from this Labour Government, Reform is condemning motorists on Holland Road to this dilapidated road until 2027 at the earliest.

“Reform were quick with the talk – now they need to get a grip and end the misery that sees residents of Derbyshire left with crippling bills to fix their cars.”

The council stated resurfacing work is scheduled at Holland Road to Whittington Hill to the B6057 Sheffield Road, and at The Glebe Way and Compass Crescent, in nearby Old Whittington, but not until the 2027-28 financial year following plans for surfacing and resurfacing at many other roads in Whittington during the 2026-27 financial year.

Pictured Are Pothole Problems Around Holland Road, Whittington.placeholder image
Pictured Are Pothole Problems Around Holland Road, Whittington.

At last year’s Budget, Labour announced a record £7.3 billion in funding to help councils get on with fixing the nation’s roads with access to full future funding allocations linked to performance.

The East Midlands Labour Group also pointed out that under the new DfT rating system Reform-run Derbyshire County Council, Leicestershire County Council and West Northamptonshire Council were all given the lowest ‘Red’ rating.

To ensure transparency from councils, 25per cent of local highway authorities’ annual funding was withheld until they published transparency reports, according to the East Midlands Labour Group, setting out their maintenance plans to allow residents and taxpayers to see how the money is being used.

A withheld £125 million in funding was unlocked at the end of last year, according to the Labour Group, following all councils successfully submitting reporting.

The Government will also be extending the Live Labs 2 programme for another year, providing up to £300,000 to help councils access and adopt more innovative approaches to maintenance, including uptake of longer-lasting, low-carbon materials for repairing roads faster, more efficiently and far less often to unlock savings for the taxpayer, lower emissions and reduce disruptive roadworks.

Opposition Derbyshire County Council Labour Group Leader, Cllr Anne Clarke, said: “We all know from talking to residents that fixing potholes is a huge priority – especially in our county which has been rated the worst for potholes of anywhere in the UK by the RAC.

“The fact that Reform has failed to get a grip of the problem after promising so much at the local elections is shameful. They should stop making empty promises to the people of Derbyshire and get on with the job.”

East Midlands Labour Group claims the Government’s record £7.3bn for local road maintenance is enough for councils to renew and improve tens of thousands of miles of roads in every corner of the country.

The Government’s Red, Amber, Green ratings are based on three key areas including the condition of roads, how much councils are spending on road repairs, and whether they are following best practice in maintaining highways.

Derbyshire County Council was among 13 councils to get a ‘Red’ rating while 125 others were ranked with an ‘Amber’ rating indicating room for improvement, and 16 received a ‘Green’ rating as an indicator of following best practice.

Councils rated ‘Red’ will receive dedicated support to bring them in line with best practices, backed by £300,000 worth of expert planning and capability assistance, according to the Labour Group, and the programme will include peer reviews where sector experts will help improve processes and provide practical advice.

Ms Alexander added: “For too long drivers have paid the price because our roads were left to deteriorate. I have heard time and again their frustration on footing the bill because they hit a pothole – money they should never have to spend in the first place.

“We’ve put our money where our mouth is, increasing the funding for councils with £7.3bn to fix roads and given them the long-term certainty they have been asking for. Now it’s over to them to spend the money wisely, and for the first time we are making sure the public can see how well councils are doing in delivering the improvements they want to see in their local area.

“This Government’s record investment will save drivers money on repairs, make roads safer and help restore pride in our communities.”

Derbyshire County Council has disputed its ‘Red’ rating and has challenged claims from the DfT, the Transport Secretary and the East Midlands Labour Group after it recently laid claim to having cleared a backlog of pothole repairs.

Cllr Hill has said the council has no idea how the DfT has judged the authority with a ‘Red’ rating and it has not told the council why it has received the lowest rating.

She added the council strongly refutes that it is not an improving highways service and the council has asked for a meeting with officials as soon as possible and it wants to invite the Transport Secretary to Derbyshire so she and others can judge the county’s roads for themselves.

Cllr Hill has argued that since May, 2025, a backlog of potholes has been cleared and the highways service is now prepared to maintain this level through winter and it has a proactive highways service working on repairs before they become issues for residents.

The Cabinet Member for Potholes added that staff this year have worked very hard to reduce potholes and deliver a better service and that the DfT judgement ‘makes no sense at all’.

Cllr Hill said that the council has made huge strides over the past four years and it has invested more in the roads this financial year than ever before after claiming it has been underfunded by the Government for road maintenance for decades.

Other local authorities have raised similar concerns with the industry title Highways Magazine about potential inaccuracies in the Government’s information which has been refuted by a DfT spokesperson.

The Local Government Association has said ‘ever-increasing pressure’ on budgets was affecting councils’ abilities to fix roads despite the DfT saying the Government was spending £7.3bn over the next four years to improve road surfaces.

Cllr Hill said: “In 2019, Derbyshire County Council received £20m in funding, so from a Conservative central government to a Conservative local authority, this is significant underfunding, where you would think the Conservatives in these positions at the time, would have communicated with each other better, so they should be ashamed of the mess they have created.

“Looking forward, we are ambitious for Derbyshire and will spend the money we have wisely. Even though our funding is increasing next year, we need many, many millions more as Derbyshire has been underfunded by successive Governments for decades.”

The council revealed that it has many jobs and repairs scheduled for roads in Whittington during the 2026-27 financial year.

These include: Resurfacing at Whitting Valley Road Roundabout; Surface dressing at Ashcroft Drive – Station Lane to Oak Bank Avenue; Surface dressing at Bower Farm Road – Station Lane to Oak Bank Avenue; Surface dressing at High Street – Station Lane to Bower Farm Road; Resurfacing at Ashcroft Drive – Service Road; Resurfacing at Roecar Close; And resurfacing at Pynot Road – Bower Farm Road to Roecar Close.

Resurfacing work is also scheduled in the following 2027-28 financial year at Holland Road – Whittington Hill to B6057 Sheffield Road, at The Glebe Way, and at Compass Crescent.

An RAC study with figures recently released by the motoring group reported that Derbyshire County Council saw the biggest increase in pothole compensation claims across three years from 2021 to the end of 2024, jumping from 224 in Covid-affected 2021 to 3,307 in 2024, all during the former Conservative administration’s tenure.

However, Cllr Hill has said compensation claims had fallen by 72per cent since May, 2025, when Reform UK took over as the controlling administration at the council.

The RAC’s analysis also claimed that pothole compensation claims made to councils in the whole of Britain rose by 90per cent between 2021 and 2024.

National Pothole Day was on Thursday, January 15, and was launched as an initiative to raise awareness of pothole problems in Britain highlighting the costs and safety risks for drivers, cyclists and pedestrians in the UK.

News you can trust since 1852
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice