Hundreds sign petition opposing removal of horse chestnut tree in Chapel Market Place

More than 800 people have signed a petition to keep the horse chestnut tree in Chapel-en-le-Frith market place after High Peak Borough Council announced the mature tree needed to be removed so toilet repair works could take place.

The council broke the news at the end of May that specialist investigations have confirmed the horse chestnut tree’s route system extends into the area required for the remedial work and needs to be removed.

They said ‘attempting to retain the tree whilst carrying out the necessary excavation would cause major damage to the roots and ultimately compromise the tree’s long-term health and stability’.

However a petition has been started which already has more than 800 signatures and many angry residents have been in touch with The Buxton Advertiser.

A Horse Chesnut tree in Chapel-en-le-Frith needs to be removed says High Peak Borough Council but hundreds of people have signed  apetition opposing this.placeholder image
A Horse Chesnut tree in Chapel-en-le-Frith needs to be removed says High Peak Borough Council but hundreds of people have signed apetition opposing this.

Leading the petition Ben Peck said: “One of Chapel-en-le-Frith’s treasured trees in the Market Place is at risk of being cut down to make way for public toilets that have been unused and out of order for years.

“The tree merits formal protection to ensure that it is preserved for future generations.

“We are therefore demanding that High Peak Borough Council grants it a Tree Preservation Order.

“The tree also has considerable landscape value.

 Chapel-en-le-Frith residents are being urged to make the most of Tenner Week and get behind the businesses taking part.placeholder image
Chapel-en-le-Frith residents are being urged to make the most of Tenner Week and get behind the businesses taking part.

“Its presence softens the built environment, contributes to the historic setting of the town, and helps maintain the distinctive character that makes Chapel-en-le-Frith unique. Mature trees such as this are increasingly important for biodiversity, environmental quality, and the overall wellbeing of the community.”

Writing on behalf of members of the community who strongly oppose this decision Josephine Kelly, a resident of Chapel for 37 years, said: “Progress has however been very slow and the work careless and untidy, making our beautiful marketplace look a total mess with railings bent and street furniture strewn carelessly across the site.

“For some weeks now work has stopped completely.

“The claim is that the tree is stopping work being finalised but no clear evidence has been offered that this is the case and there are rumours in the town that the contract has had to be re-tendered.”

She says the community is of course ‘concerned about the cost this drawn out work is incurring’.

“After the debacle with the park in recent years costing locals thousands of pounds in legal fees and the loss of facilities for the communities' children, residents are rightly concerned about this sudden change of approach, the slow and poor work and the fiscal and environmental costs to the town.”

She put forward a suggestion that the tree is to be kept and the toilets should be moved to the park ‘where they would be much more widely used by the community’.

“Something purpose built could be created making it easier to maintain, more energy efficient and now that the park is manned they could be locked up every night.”

Sam Jenkinson said: “Tree or toilets, sack the toilets off, save the tree. Put the toilets somewhere else or not at all.”

Theresa Leatherbarrow seconded this and said: “Surely it would be cheaper just to build toilets in a different location and leave the tree where it is.

“That tree is an iconic part of Chapel Market Place.”

And Turner Chris added: “I sat yesterday having a coffee and looking at the tree in all its glory and tried to imagine a scenario whereby the toilets will be magnificent and worth sacrificing the tree and it doesn’t exist.”

Ben Peck, said: “The Market Place is the heart of Chapel, and the horse chestnut tree makes a significant contribution to its character and identity.

“From the photos that we can find, the tree has stood there for the best part of 100 years – so for Councillor Greenhalgh to simply say it is going without any real thought for the community or consultation feels like a real kick in the teeth for the town.

“We want our Market Place back, but the building work on the toilets is already nearly a year behind schedule.

“Now that they have found that the old toilets are in a worse state of repair than originally thought, and before more public money is flushed away, surely there should be a conversation about what is the right way forward.”

So far more than 800 people have signed a petition to oppose the plans to remove the tree.

Ben said: “The strength of the feeling suggests there has to be another way.”

We put the concerns raised by residents to High Peak Borough Council.

The spokesperson said the work has been slower than they hoped due to ‘challenging and unforeseen circumstances being discovered once the work commenced, including the impact of the tree’s roots on the integrity of the structures’.

The spokesperson said any mess and untidiness issues caused during the work will be ‘remedied’ but the tree is the factor causing the delay.

They clarified that the work has not been re-tendered.

The spokesperson said: “These works are unrelated to Chapel-en-le-Frith Parish Council and the issues over the MUGA in their park.

“High Peak Borough Council is working to bring the much valued and needed toilet block back into use at the earliest possible point but is having to mitigate the issues with the site, including the tree.

“We always work to ensure best value and meet our obligations when spending taxpayers’ money.”

This is a commercial contract and so the information on cost, they say, has to remain confidential.

The spokesperson said: “We are working to bring the facilities into use in their current location as a refurbishment, and available for future generations with a significant investment as part of our borough-wide investment in High Peak Borough Council owned facilities.”

When asked about why the toilets could not be moved to the park the council said the Memorial Park is the responsibility of Chapel-en-le-Frith Parish Council.

Addressing residents' concerns about the lack of consultation the spokesperson said: “There is no requirement to consult.

“Much as we would like to retain both the toilet block and the tree, we simply can’t make this happen, as explained.

“This is the reality we face. Since concerns were first raised about the potential loss of trees, we have explored every possible option to retain the Chestnut tree.

“However, specialist surveys have confirmed that its roots extend into the area required for the essential remedial works, meaning this tree will need to be removed to enable the project to be completed safely and without further delay, with replacement planting to be provided in a suitable location.”

News you can trust since 1852
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice