Derbyshire second home owners convert properties into holiday lets to avoid paying double tax

A Derbyshire council charging hundreds of second home owners double in tax has led to a minor reduction, but some have just been converted into holiday lets to avoid the charge.

Derbyshire Dales District Council, which oversees much of the most rural and tourism-heavy parts of the county, has been charging double council tax on second homes since April in a bid to reduce their numbers.

It is hoped that fewer second homes would free up more homes for Derbyshire Dales residents or at the very least ensure homes are occupied for more of the year, with people contributing to the local economy.

The council has been pushing for action on second homes and holiday lets for years, with Government legislation currently only referring to second home tax options, which were delayed to start from April this year.

It is hoped that fewer second homes would free up more homes for Derbyshire Dales residents or at the very least ensure homes are occupied for more of the year, with people contributing to the local economy.placeholder image
It is hoped that fewer second homes would free up more homes for Derbyshire Dales residents or at the very least ensure homes are occupied for more of the year, with people contributing to the local economy.

Other legislation to make it mandatory for conversions of homes into holiday lets has not yet come forward after being pushed along through the previous Conservative government.

A district council report updates on the impact of the current second home tax.

It says there had been 1,000 second homes in January last year and since then this had reduced by 11 per cent (113 fewer), to 887.

Meanwhile, the number of holiday lets has reduced from 1,237 in January last year by 4.8 per cent (59 fewer) to 1,178.

A key detail highlighted in the report is that since January, 79 second homes have been converted into holiday lets, pushing the problem property from one category causing an issue, into another.

Council officials say: “Key findings indicate that the number of second homes has reduced, with a significant proportion being returned to sole residences and a smaller number converting to holiday lets/empty homes.

“Analysis suggests that the premium is also acting as a deterrent for the purchase of new second homes in the district.

“Several Derbyshire Dales residents reacted to the premium by expressing plans to convert their second home into a holiday let to avoid the charge.”

Council officials say most second homes fall into tax band C, while the total majority are in bands A-C, supporting the claim that these properties are some of the more affordable homes in the district.

The Dales has been often listed as one of the most unaffordable areas to live outside of London due to its house prices, with developer Gladman referring to it last year as being in the centre of an affordable house “crisis”.

They say the tax has so far brought in an extra £1.85 million in council tax, which will be shared around the authorities it is owed to – 75 per cent (£1.3 million) to Derbyshire County Council and around 10 per cent (£250,000) to the district.

Officials are now asking councillors to allow two further exceptions to the second homes tax for people who have bought a propertty which will become their primary residence but which needs significant renovations first, alongside owners of rural huts with no water or energy supply, used intermittently as a secondary dwelling.

These, if approved, would be added to exceptions such as military service, annexes, homes marketed for sale or let, job-related homes and those undergoing probate.

News you can trust since 1852
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice