Biggest talking point of the week - plans for a new Buxton Travelodge
More than 150 have spoken out about the plans to build a new Travelodge in the former High Peak Halls in Buxton making it our most talked about article of the week.
Plans have been submitted to High Peak Borough Council to demolish two thirds of the former student accommodation and build a new 70-bed hotel with larger parking facilities.
And here’s what Buxton Advertiser readers thought about the proposal.
Ellie Mole said: “Walking distance to the station, great central location in a tourist town.


“Actually sounds sensible. And as far as I remember, travelodge don’t do meals so another boost for our local restaurants.”
Melandra Smith said: “Sounds fine to me - we need a hospital hub but this is a good use too.”
Robert Parker agreed and said: “Great idea better than being derelict and a lovely newly built building going to waste in Buxton.”
However Greg Boulton thought there was nothing for people to come to the town anymore.
He said: “There’s not a great deal to visit in Buxton anymore.
“Just got back from the Cotswolds, small little town.had around 150 shops none of which were charity, vape or Turkish barbers.
“Buxton had had its day unfortunately.”
John Charles Saunders countered and said: “Don't be so cynical. You provide affordable hotel accommodation you get visitors.
“You get visitors, you get economy, with economy you get shops.
Sam Longden agreed and said: “If retailers aren’t interested in investing in the site, then what can be done. Travelodge are interested and appear to be the only ones who are.”
Sean Ryan thought the town was over saturated with holiday accommodation and said: “I don’t have an answer for what it should be, however, I can’t see a travel lodge being great for Buxton, we already have the Crescent, the Palace, the Old Hall, Premier Inn, Lee Wood, Air BNBs, bed and breakfasts.
“We are only a small town, perhaps change it into affordable housing for Buxton youngsters.
Jill Neves agreed and said: “Don’t we have a housing problem.”
Should the plans for the Travelodge Hotel be approved the parking provision will be enhanced from the existing 42 spaces (including four disabled bays) to a total of 60 spaces, comprising four disabled bays, eight dedicated staff spaces, and four electric vehicle charging points.
There was some concern by readers about who would be staying in the hotel.
Paul Howard said: “Won't get enough trade so will fill with asylum, it's just a loop hole for the original plan that got knocked back few years ago.” In 2023 proposals for a 288-bed asylum centre were put forward by Serco, the Home Office’s asylum accommodation provider, to be based out of the University of Derby’s halls of residence in Buxton.
This caused widespread concern amongst the community and led to protests and petition and in 2024 the former Immigration Minister, Tom Pursglove, said the postcodes SK17 7 and SK17 6 would never be used as housing for those seeking asylum.
Speaking on X, formerly Twitter, Travelodge UK clarified and said it ‘does not have any contracts to house asylum seekers’.