GP surgeries in Derbyshire could have tens of thousands of 'ghost patients'

GP surgeries in Derbyshire could be receiving payments for tens of thousands of patients who may not exist, analysis of NHS figures reveals.

By Lucy Roberts
Wednesday, 19th June 2019, 1:49 pm
Around 42,100 ( 4%) could be 'ghost patients' in Derbyshire.
Around 42,100 ( 4%) could be 'ghost patients' in Derbyshire.

The NHS Counter Fraud Authority recently launched a national probe into so-called ghost patients, for which practices still get funding even though they may have left the area or died.

The latest Office for National Statistics data shows an estimated 1,015,700 people live in the NHS Derby and Derbyshire CCG area, but around 1,057,700 patients were registered with GP surgeries at the start of June.

This means around 42,100 ( 4%) could be ghost patients.

The ONS estimate was published in 2017, so some of the disparity could be down to changes in the local population.

But it is extremely unlikely that this accounts for all the excess patients, as the average yearly population growth for the area was just 0.5% between 2012 and 2017.

The NHS paid an average of £ 157.49 per registered patient in the 2017-18 financial year.

Based on this figure, GP surgeries in Derby and Derbyshire could currently be receiving around £6.6 million for ghost patients each year.

The NHS Counter Fraud Authority estimates that up to £88 million was incorrectly claimed by GPs across England in the 2017-18 financial year.

A spokesperson for the organisation said previous analysis had identified a discrepancy between the number of people registered at GP surgeries and the population.

They added: “Our priority this year will be to assess whether these discrepancies remain, and if they do, conduct further analysis to establish their nature and whether part of this is due to fraudulent activity or not.”

But Professor Helen Stokes-Lampard, chair of the Royal College of GPs, said: "The insinuation that GPs – some of the most trusted professionals in society - are complicit in defrauding the health service is shocking and will be incredibly hurtful for hard-working GPs and their teams, who are struggling to deliver care to more than 1 million patients a day across the country, with insufficient time, resources or workforce to do so."

She said it is important to make sure patient lists are kept up-to-date, adding that “so-called ghost patients” are nothing sinister, but the result of a “records management issue”.