Armed Derbyshire man gets a community order after chasing a neighbour with a hockey stick

An armed man who chased a neighbour through a Derbyshire town centre while wielding a hockey stick after a dispute over potted plants has been given a community order.

Thursday, 27th June 2019, 12:42 pm

Chesterfield magistrates’ court heard on June 25 how Abdel-aal Ali Mohammed-Ali, 54, of Market Place, Buxton, pleaded guilty to using threatening behaviour after he pursued the neighbour across Market Place while waving a hockey stick.

Prosecuting solicitor Mark Fielding told a previous hearing there was background of ill feeling between the two men and there had been a confrontation between them over a potted plant.

Mr Fielding added that the complainant went shopping and was returning home across Buxton Market Place in the middle of the day when the defendant ran towards him with a hockey stick shouting and making threats.

Buxton Market Place
Buxton Market Place

The court heard that the incident which was captured on CCTV.

The complainant stated he suffers with anxiety after he had once been stabbed in the face by someone else in a separate incident and he stated he has post-traumatic stress disorder and the latest incident had heightened his anxiety.

He also claimed that all he had done was ask the defendant to stay away from his stairwell and plants because they live in the block of flats.

Former University security officer Mohammed-Ali pleaded guilty to using threatening behaviour after the incident on September 21, 2018.

Chesterfield magistrates' court.

Defence solicitor James Riley also told the previous hearing Mohammed-Ali has mental health issues and he had felt threatened and had claimed that he had been assaulted by the complainant and had acted in self defence but went too far.

Mr Riley added that the complainant had referred to his neighbour as “Ali Bongo” in a police statement because he thought he was “crackers”.

But Mohammed-Ali claims he has suffered abuse from his neighbour, according to Mr Riley, with sexual comments and cultural and racist references and a witness said they had heard the complainant making provocative, howling noises.

The court heard that the complainant is a keen horticulturist and according to Mr Riley he grows a lot of things which allegedly obscure views at the flats.

Mohammed-Ali was sentenced to a 12 month community order with a Rehabilitation Activity Requirement and 40 hours of unpaid work.

He was also ordered to pay £85 costs and an £85 victim surcharge.